Skip to the swatches
Own

Sample No. 0272

Blue Spruce No. 04: A Smoother Built Around MagnaCut Steel

Woodworking & Carving The Lost Scrolls of Handwork

Blue Spruce's No. 04 puts knife-grade CPM MagnaCut in a smoothing iron. Here's what the steel, the 52° angle and the US$545 price mean in the shop.

Blue Spruce No. 04: A Smoother Built Around MagnaCut Steel

Blue Spruce Toolworks has released its first smoothing plane, and the No. 04 deserves a close look for one reason above the rest: the iron is CPM MagnaCut, a stainless steel better known in knife blades than in plane irons. That's an unusual pick for a woodworking tool, and it raises a fair question. What does this steel actually give a woodworker who already keeps O1, A2 or PM-V11 irons on the shelf?

The iron is 3/16-inch thick, and the body is built differently from most smoothers. Rather than a single casting, Blue Spruce machines five separate stainless-steel components, assembles them, and then machines the assembly to its finished shape. The handles are Bolivian rosewood, also called Pau Ferro.

What MagnaCut is and how it compares

Most plane makers have settled on three steels. O1 is the easy one. It sharpens quickly and takes a keen edge, but it dulls faster in abrasive timber and rusts if you ignore it. A2 holds its edge longer and resists edge damage well, though it takes more effort to sharpen and still isn't stainless. PM-V11, developed by Veritas specifically for woodworking tools, aims for a middle path: better edge retention and impact resistance than O1 and A2, while still sharpening on conventional waterstones. Veritas reports that its PM-V11 irons hold an edge at least twice as long as its A2 irons under its own testing conditions. That's a useful number, as long as you read it with those conditions in mind.

MagnaCut comes at the problem from a different direction. Metallurgist Dr Larrin Thomas developed it as a powder-metallurgy stainless tool steel for knife making. Its chromium, vanadium, niobium and molybdenum content produces an unusual mix of corrosion resistance, toughness and wear resistance. It was designed to avoid chromium carbides in its heat-treated structure, which helps keep corrosion resistance high, while vanadium and niobium carbides supply the wear resistance. Blue Spruce heat-treats its irons to between 61 and 63 HRC. That's a hard, impressive material, but how a steel performs in a knife edge doesn't automatically tell you how it will perform on a board of difficult, reversing grain.

The sharpening question

Here's the thing: the hard vanadium and niobium carbides that make MagnaCut wear well are also what make sharpening a legitimate concern. Still, hard carbides don't mean the steel can't be sharpened on ordinary stones. Dr Thomas has reported that MagnaCut sharpens successfully on conventional aluminium-oxide stones, including Shapton Glass stones. Diamond and CBN abrasives work well too, though they aren't mandatory.

Be realistic about waterstones and oilstones, though. They will get there, but slowly and tediously. Diamond stones or a CBN wheel are the better match for this iron. That means a woodworker buying the No. 04 may need to add diamond or CBN abrasives to the bench just to keep up with it, and that's a real cost to factor in alongside the plane itself.

Blue Spruce does some of the groundwork before the iron leaves the factory. The back is surface-ground, lapped with diamond slurry and polished. The 25° primary bevel is ground, and the 30° micro-bevel is honed and stropped. In other words, the blade arrives close to ready for work rather than leaving initial preparation to you. Long-term edge maintenance is still the open question, though. I'd want reports from woodworkers using the plane for months before ranking it against O1, A2 and PM-V11.

Does the 52° cutting angle change anything?

The other interesting feature is the geometry. The No. 04 is bevel-up, with a 22° bed and a 30° micro-bevel, which gives an effective cutting angle of 52°. A conventional bevel-down bench plane sits at 45°. The reasoning behind the steeper angle is straightforward. Difficult grain, especially reversing and highly figured grain, can make a plane iron lift and tear the fibres rather than slicing them cleanly. A higher effective angle changes how the iron meets those fibres and can reduce tear-out considerably.

But this isn't a new idea. High-angle planes and different blade geometries have been part of the hand-tool toolkit for a long time. A bevel-up plane has one practical advantage: you change the effective angle by changing the honing bevel. A plane with a 12° bed and a 38° bevel, for example, produces a 50° cutting angle, so you get flexibility without buying a second plane. A toothing plane followed by a scraper or a carefully set smoother is the traditional route. The No. 04 offers a convenient ready-made solution, but it isn't introducing a capability the hand-tool woodworker didn't already have.

Build, specifications and price

The five-piece machined body is the design choice I find most interesting. Blue Spruce claims this construction produces a more stable body than a casting. The plane measures 11 inches overall, with a 10-inch sole, a 2-inch-wide iron and a total weight of 4.5 pounds (2kg). It also features a Norris-style adjuster and an adjustable mouth. According to the manufacturer, it needs no initial fettling, sole lapping or sharpening before use.

The price is where the No. 04 gets harder to justify. The listed introductory price is US$545, reduced from US$600, and the manufacturer quotes approximately 12 to 16 weeks to build an order. That puts it firmly at the premium end of the market. Lie-Nielsen and Veritas both offer excellent No. 4 smoothers at considerably lower prices, and those are established designs with a long record in workshops. The question is whether the Blue Spruce's extra features add enough benefit to cover the gap.

Close-up detail of the plane’s construction and blade arrangement.

Do we really need MagnaCut in a hand plane?

This is where I find myself questioning the design direction. MagnaCut was built for knives, where corrosion resistance matters a great deal given exposure to moisture, food acids and outdoor conditions. A plane lives a different life. Rust is an irritation in a humid shop, but most of us already have routines that handle it: a light coat of oil and sensible storage go a long way. Edge retention matters, but it's only part of the equation. A plane iron also has to be easy to bring back to sharp, without turning every touch-up into a lengthy job.

PM-V11 already strikes that balance well, and O1 remains an excellent choice for anyone who values quick, straightforward honing. I'd like to see a proper comparison between MagnaCut and PM-V11 after both have been used for an extended period, in the same timber and under the same conditions. Until that exists, I'd treat any claim that one is clearly superior in woodworking with caution.

Final thoughts

Credit to Blue Spruce for trying something different. The No. 04 is an interesting piece of engineering, and I appreciate the attention to blade preparation and the decision to ship the plane ready for work. Those are practical touches that make a difference on day one. Still, I'm not convinced MagnaCut offers enough over established woodworking steels to be the headline feature. The 52° angle is useful, but other bevel-up planes can reach it, and PM-V11 already delivers strong edge retention without complicating the sharpening routine.

For a tool collector, the No. 04 will be an attractive addition to the bench. For the working woodworker, a good Veritas or Lie-Nielsen smoother will likely do the job just as well and leave more money for timber. The work coming off the plane is what counts, not the name stamped on the iron.

Source: The Lost Scrolls of Handwork · journeymansjournel.wordpress.com

Pairs well with